May 2017 Q3 a.
Djaba Ltd uses an organisational structure in which most power and critical decision making responsibilities are concentrated with a few key leaders. The organisation often houses its primary decision makers or executives in a central headquarters with offices and meeting areas for leaders to discuss business.
Required:
Identify and explain THREE advantages and TWO disadvantages of this organisational structure to Djaba Ltd. (10 marks)
View Solution
Advantages of centralization.
- Decisions can be coordinated more easily, and management has better control over decisions.
- Goal congruence. Decisions taken centrally should are based on overall objectives, whereas decentralized decisions may be influenced by short-term or local objectives of the people making the decisions.
- Standardization. For example, in any country McDonald’s customers expect to find standard menus and pricing. If managers were allowed to take decisions about changing menus or prices, this could undermine the business model.
- Resource allocation. Centralized decision making allows resource usage to be coordinated effectively between different functions and divisions, based on overall corporate objectives.
- Economies of scale. Companies might be able to get bulk discounts if they coordinate all their purchasing requirements and make a single order.
- Quick decision making. When a quick decision is required in response to a crisis, it may not be practical to involve local managers. (Any 3)
Disadvantages of centralization.
- Reduced morale and job satisfaction. Local managers and divisional staff may be frustrated at their inability to take decisions, and this could reduce their job satisfaction and motivation.
- The fact that senior managers take all the decisions and do not delegate any could also increase the pressure and stress on senior managers.
- Limited opportunities. If junior managers are not given any opportunities for decision making this could hinder their career development, by preventing them from gaining experience which could be useful in more senior management positions.
- Imperfect information. Local managers may have greater knowledge about operational activities or local market conditions than senior management or head office staff. Therefore, senior management may have to delegate some decisions, or else risk damaging the quality of decisions taken due to their imperfect information.
- Communication time. Although centralisation can be useful for making rapid decisions( eg in a crisis,) it may take longer for decisions taken centrally to be communicated to different divisions and functions than if the decisions had been taken locally. (Any 2)