At its recent Annual General Meeting, management of NTM was highly criticized for two major scandals that occurred in the organization during the year. In one case, newspapers reported that the management of the company connived with officials at the port to undervalue imports in order to pay lower taxes. In the other case, it was reported that the accountant leaked information to his friend who was bidding for a contract in the company. The Board Chairman, who is also the Chief Executive Officer of the company apologized for these incidents but did not disclose that the company had been sued in respect of the first case. He went on to promise the shareholders that the fortunes of the company would change dramatically by the end of the new year as the company was going to start exporting its products to Europe within the next few weeks.
Required:
a) Identify and explain THREE situations that are in conflict with the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC)’s Code of Ethics. (6 marks)
View Solution
(i) In the first situation, the fundamental principle of integrity was violated. Accountants are required to act with integrity (honesty and truthfulness) while they are performing their duties. By allowing customs official to undervalue the imports, the accountant’s behavior which can be described as bribery of an official and cheating of the state pointed to his dishonesty.
(ii) The second situation was an issue of confidentiality. Any information that is withheld from the public during a bidding process is supposed to be kept as a secret. Revealing this information to anyone who is not supposed to have it violates the fundamental principle of confidentiality.
(iii) The CEO’s refusal to disclose information relating the court suit violates the principle of disclosure. Governance regulations and codes require that organisations make disclosures about the board, internal control reviews, going concern status and relations with stakeholders.